Mitch Mustain committed to play football for the University of Arkansas on August 16, 2005 after a long and grueling recruitment. While trying to make an important life decision, Mustain became one of the most scrutinized, analyzed, and debated recruits in Arkansas’ history. The press coverage was immense and his personal life became the subject of thousands of articles and many sports talk shows in the local and national media. To say it was insane would be an understatement. It was a circus built and constructed by the media and the fans flocked in groves to witness.
There was no question that Mustain was viewed as the “future” of Arkansas football. He was the highest ranked recruit ever to come out of the state of Arkansas and by season end he was the top quarterback in the nation. He was awarded every national honor a high school football player can be awarded. It would have been a travesty had he left the state and possibly the end of any coach who allowed it to happen.
He had visited at least 12 universities in less than a year, and on more than one occasion had come close to committing to another school. While he truly wanted to stay in his home state, he had serious concerns about Coach Houston Nutt. His history with the treatment and development of quarterbacks (or lack thereof), his inability to develop a balanced offense, and other issues that had come to the surface during recruiting. But ultimately he felt it was important to make a decision prior to his senior season, and he desperately wanted to play for Arkansas. So he took Nutt at his word that things would be “different” and committed.
His concerns regarding the commitment to the University of Arkansas began to surface early in the 2005 season. As Arkansas struggled, Mustain watched. He watched as Arkansas lost to the traditional “bottom feeders” in the SEC. He watched as Nutt failed, again, to develop even a hint of a respectable passing game. He watched the receivers block and the quarterbacks “hand off.” He watched as, in desperation, Coach Nutt pulled freshman quarterback Casey Dick’s red-shirt with only 4 games left in the season and struggled to end his first season 2-2 as the starter.
For the first time ever, he intently watched Arkansas football and clearly understood their past, and dreaded his future.
On December 5, 2005 after Arkansas’ dismal 4-7 season, Mustain decommitted. He informed Nutt of his decision in a private meeting, however within two hours the media was aware of their conversation.
For several months during 2005, several key individuals within the Arkansas program discussed hiring Mustain’s high school coach, Gus Malzahn, as a position coach. An Arkansas booster and Board of Trustee member, Jim Lindsey, approached Mustain's family regarding this issue on no less than three occasions.
After the news that Mustain would not be attending the UofA was made public by someone in the administration and announced by the press on December 6th, Malzahn made the decision not to go to work for Arkansas.
He knew that if he were to go on staff as a position coach, he would have little influence over the offense. His “football philosophy” differed greatly from what Nutt had produced during his 8 years at Arkansas. And he and Mustain each privately shared the same concerns regarding the future of the Arkansas program.
On Tuesday, December 6 Head Coach Malzahn presided over an assembly at Springdale High School for Mustain’s Gatorade POY award. Wednesday December 7, 2005, still employed as the AD and coach at Springdale, Malzahn flew to New York to join Mitch Mustain during a Parade Player of the Year photo shoot.
On Thursday, December 8th Malzahn and his wife abruptly left a day earlier than scheduled to return to Fayetteville.
Nutt announced at a press conference on December 9th, four days after Mustain’s decommitment, that Malzahn was the offensive coordinator, and would have full control of the offense.
Arkansas was coming off two straight losing seasons and the threat of losing several of the top recruits in the state, one being a top national recruit, put added pressure on the program.
The “powers-that-be” understood that this was the only way Malzahn would come to work for the program and the only hope Mustain might reconsider. So with no college experience, Malzahn was hired and it was immediately made known that he was the “offensive coordinator,” the program would change their offensive philosophy and he would have control. Houston Nutt, after very publicly proclaiming for 8 straight years that he did not need or want an offensive coordinator and that it was the greatest part of his job as a coach, turned control over to a high school coach.
However, in a Morning News article dated February 18, 2007 Nutt stated,
"Q: Let’s just start with the hiring of Gus and the recruiting of the Springdale group. Was it clear from Coach Broyles that you needed to hire an offensive coordinator?
A: Yes, it was clear after two tough seasons of 5-6 and 4-7 that (we) really thought the direction that needed to go in was to get an offensive coordinator. And so we sought out on that search, and actually hired Gus before that, before the offensive coordinator was in place. Hired him first and with the intention of either being quarterback or receiver coach and then getting a guy like we pursued David Cutcliffe, David Lee...
Q: Those were the three I heard-Cutcliffe, David Lee and Wittke. Did you offer any of those?
A: I offered David Cutcliffe and David Lee. "
David Cutcliffe has never acknowledged an offer from the University of Arkansas and no offer has ever been reported. Cutcliffe was named the offensive coordinator at the University of Tennessee and was on staff as of November 23. 2005.
Nutt also stated in a radio interview on February 21,2007 with Drive Time Sports that Gus was originally hired as a position coach only, either as the quarterback or wide receiver coach. He said he and Gus attempted to “recruit” David Lee together to come back as the QB coach and the offensive coordinator.
Had Arkansas hired him as an assistant coach prior to late December 8th with the intention of conducting a search for an offensive coordinator, the University would have been in violation of NCAA regulations prohibiting coaches from contact with recruits.
When exactly was Gus Malzahn hired and for what position? Nutt’s time line of the events do not make any sense. It appears as if he may be attempting to re-write history.
Many fans questioned the sincerity of Nutt’s commitment to Malzahn and whether he wanted Malzahn as the offensive coordinator. Nutt had said for some time that he wanted Malzahn on staff “in some capacity,” but turning over his responsibilities with the offense went against every proclamation he had previously made. It was not surprising that Nutt and his staff harbored a resentment towards the decision that was forced on their program.
Malzahn would experience the disdain and defiance shortly after joining the staff.
Fans were already in an uproar following the dismal 2004 and 2005 seasons and Mustain’s decommittment added fuel to the raging fire. They had lost faith in their coach during the prior two seasons and now they had lost faith in his ability to recruit the top kids in their own state. Three other top Arkansas recruits from Springdale were already headed to other schools where no promises had to be made. The coaches had proven records, their players were developed and their teams won games.
With his reputation and ego seriously bruised from the daily fallout and speculations, Nutt personally visited with Frank Broyles and convinced him to allow Nutt to pull Mustain’s offer. His rationale was that Mustain would be a distraction, both during the remainder of the recruiting period and on the team if he indeed changed his mind. He no longer wanted him even if Mustain wanted them. He was personally insulted and appalled by the player’s scorn. After all, Nutt had been the first to offer the home-state player before he ever started a high school game. However Malzahn convinced those close to Broyles that all was not lost and that he truly believed that given the opportunity to convince Mustain that the program was sincere, he would stay home. After all, he really did want to be a Razorback. He just needed a reason.
The road to convincing Mustain that the program was sincere in their bold commitment, one they intended to keep, was difficult. He did not believe Broyles and Nutt were sincere in their hiring of Malzahn. But several very powerful individuals close to the program, including Jim Lindsey made specific assurances. There would be no question as to the path Arkansas’ future would take. Nutt had been given 8 years to prove he was capable of making a transition and had failed. Malzahn would have control of the direction and development of the offense and the promises would be kept.
On January 16, 2006, with his trust placed in the hands of those he believed powerful enough to keep those promises, Mitch Mustain recommitted to the University of Arkansas.
Placing his own integrity on the line, he immediately went to work on his best friend, Damian Williams who had committed to Florida, as well as several other key recruits. He became the University’s biggest advocate, convincing key recruits that with the talent in place on the team, the addition of their skills and talents and with the determination and ability of Malzahn to revitalize the program, Arkansas would soon be contending with the top schools in the nation. His convictions were strong and he shared the vision and confidence Malzahn had instilled in him with the recruits. Much of that confidence came from the belief that they had all the support they would need to take Arkansas football to a new level in division 1 football.
On signing day, Arkansas landed the top pro-style QB and seven of the top receivers and tight ends in the nation.
Houston Nutt has maintained in all his post 2006 season interviews that Gus was allowed to run the offense. However, he repeatedly stated that it was a “collective effort” and that the offense was actually structured by the entire staff during the coach meetings throughout game weeks.
There seems to be a contradiction in those two assertions.He has stated that it was Malzahn’s decision not to run his signature offense.
When asked in the press conference when he was hired as the OC in December 2005 Malzahn stated, “I am what I am. We will run the hurry up.”
Malzahn has stated privately that initially the staff seemed “reluctantly open” to running a spread offense and a “hurry-up offense” however, by midseason little to no effort was made to incorporate his offensive philosophy into the game plans.
After the Auburn game, Houston Nutt had regained complete control and Malzahn was seriously limited.
The only time the offense ran a hurry up, no huddle offense was during the USC game. It resulted in a successful 80-yard touchdown drive in 1 ½ minutes.The Hurry-Up spread offense has been Gus Malzahn’s signature offense.
It was what he was hired to bring to the Arkansas Razorbacks as stated by Nutt during the press conference in December 2005. According to the statements made by Nutt during his radio and newspaper articles, it would appear that Malzahn abandoned “who” he is in favor of an offense by committee.
Malzahn has not spoken publicly regarding his time at Arkansas. However, it should be obvious to any fan of Arkansas football that he was not hired for the purposes stated by Nutt and the University administration.
Tags: Uncategorized by realhogreporter
No Comments »